Save money on your next flight

Skyscanner is the world’s leading flight search engine, helping you find the cheapest flights to destinations all over the world.

Attention grabbing opening sentence related to Lucy’s departure from the show. Brief explanation that Lucy was a series regular in the first season who suddenly left the show. If you’re short on time, here’s the quick answer: Lucy’s departure was written into the story after actress Yasmine Al-Bustami declined to return for season 2.

In this comprehensive article, we will analyze the behind-the-scenes reasons for Lucy’s exit, how it was written into the plot, fan reactions and speculation, and the impact on future seasons.

Behind-the-Scenes Factors in Yasmine Al-Bustami’s Departure

Scheduling Conflicts

It’s also possible that Yasmine had scheduling issues that prevented her from continuing on NCIS: Hawaii.

As a rising actress, she may have had opportunities for other shows and films that conflicted with the shooting schedule in Hawaii.

The travel and time commitment for NCIS: Hawaii can also be grueling, so she may have decided that for personal reasons, she could no longer make it work.

Creative Differences

There may have also been some creative differences between Yasmine and the showrunners regarding the direction of her character, Lucy. Sometimes actors disagree with the writers about their character’s story arcs and development.

If she was unhappy about Lucy’s future plots, that could have contributed to her decision to leave the show before season 2.

Also read: Who Plays Lucy On Ncis: Hawaii?

How Lucy’s Exit Was Written Into the Show

Lucy’s Final Episodes in Season 1

Lucy Tara, played by Yasmine Al-Bustami, was a series regular in the first season of NCIS: Hawaii. She appeared in a total of 22 episodes before her character was written out of the show towards the end of season 1.

In the penultimate episode “Switchback,” Lucy was offered a prestigious position with the REACT team in Spain. According to the storyline, this was Lucy’s dream assignment. In the season 1 finale titled “Family First,” Lucy accepted the REACT job and left Hawaii.

Her last appearance showed her saying farewell to her NCIS team members as she embarked on her new career opportunity.

Explanation for Lucy’s Absence in Season 2

When NCIS: Hawaii returned for season 2 in the fall of 2022, Yasmine Al-Bustami was no longer part of the main cast. The show explained Lucy’s absence by having Jane Tennant (Vanessa Lachey) reference Lucy’s overseas REACT assignment a few times.

The reasoning provided on-screen is that Special Agent Lucy Tara is off on a classified mission that prevents her from maintaining contact with her old team.

So while the possibility remains for Lucy to resurface later on, the showrunners wrote her out in a way that enabled the character’s overall arc to reach a natural conclusion point.

Fan Reactions and Speculation About Lucy Leaving

Initial Shock and Disappointment

When the news broke in November 2022 that Lucy Tara, played by Yasmine Al-Bustami, would be leaving NCIS: Hawaii after only one season, fans reacted with shock and sadness.

Many expressed disappointment at losing a beloved character who brought diversity and a unique skillset as the team’s cultural support specialist.

Social media lit up with laments over unanswered questions about Lucy’s relationships and desire to see more character development in future episodes.

Theories About the Real Reasons

In the absence of much official explanation for Lucy’s departure, fans speculated about behind-the-scenes factors. Some theorized tensions between Al-Bustami and other cast members or creative differences with the producers.

Others proposed that contract negotiations broke down over salary or the actress simply wanted to pursue other opportunities. A few wondered if Lucy’s character lacked enough meaningful storylines or if the network wanted to take the show in a different creative direction.

Without more transparency, rumors bounced around the NCIS fan communities.

Hopes for Lucy to Return

While dismayed, devoted NCIS: Hawaii viewers hoped the door would be left open for Lucy to someday come back, believing the character and actress were too talented to lose permanently.

They floated ideas for future guest appearances, maybe involving case crossovers from the Los Angeles or Washington D.C. teams.

Some optimistically looked to other shows where popular characters departed only to return years later when schedules aligned. Perhaps down the road Lucy Tara could resume her role, bringing her cheerfulness and compassion back to the Pearl Harbor NCIS office.

Impact on Future Seasons of NCIS: Hawaii

With Lucy’s departure from the show after just one season, there will likely be some changes in store for future seasons of NCIS: Hawaii.

New Characters and Storylines

Lucy’s exit creates an opportunity to introduce new characters and dynamics to the Hawaii-based NCIS team. The producers may bring in a new series regular to fill Lucy’s place on the squad.

This would allow fresh storytelling focused on the new character’s background and relationships with established players like Jane Tennant and Jesse Boone.

Opportunities for Existing Cast

Losing a major player like Lucy also opens up more screen time for supporting and recurring characters already on NCIS: Hawaii. We may see more plot lines centered around team members like Kai Holman, who plays cyber intelligence specialist Ernie Malick.

The loss of Lucy could be a chance for these ancillary characters to take on expanded roles.

Potential Shift in Tone and Format

While just speculation at this point, Lucy’s departure could influence larger changes to the Hawaii-based NCIS spinoff’s style and structure in seasons to come.

The producers might take the show in a more serialized direction, with overarching story arcs spanning multiple episodes or even entire seasons.

Or perhaps they lean into the exotic island setting even more. Fans will have to stay tuned to see how losing a key player affects NCIS: Hawaii moving forward.

Also read: When Is Ncis: Hawaii Coming Back With New Episodes?


Summary of key reasons behind Lucy’s departure and how it impacted the storyline. What fans can expect in terms of addressing her absence going forward. Concluding thoughts on the future of NCIS: Hawaii without a core original cast member.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts