Save money on your next flight

Skyscanner is the world’s leading flight search engine, helping you find the cheapest flights to destinations all over the world.

Planning a trip to Hawaii and wondering if you should rent a car or rely on rideshare services like Uber or Lyft during your stay? This comprehensive guide will walk you through the pros and cons of both options to help you decide what’s best for your Hawaiian getaway.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: renting a car is generally the better option in Hawaii for the flexibility, convenience, and potential cost savings it provides over using rideshare services like Uber or Lyft.

In this article, we’ll compare renting a car versus using Uber in Hawaii across several factors: convenience, flexibility, cost, safety, and going off the beaten path. We’ll also provide tips for saving money on a rental car and getting around efficiently without one. Read on for a detailed breakdown to help you make the best decision for your Hawaii trip!

Convenience and Flexibility

Renting a Car Provides Maximum Convenience and Flexibility

When it comes to exploring the beautiful islands of Hawaii, renting a car offers unparalleled convenience and flexibility. Having your own vehicle allows you to create your own itinerary and explore the islands at your own pace. Whether you want to chase waterfalls in Maui, visit the active volcanoes in Big Island, or simply enjoy the scenic drives along the coastline, having a rental car gives you the freedom to do so. You can easily stop wherever you want, take detours to hidden gems, and enjoy the breathtaking views that Hawaii has to offer.

Renting a car also allows you to easily access remote and less crowded areas, which may not be easily accessible by public transportation or ride-sharing services. This gives you the opportunity to discover the lesser-known treasures of Hawaii and have a more authentic and immersive experience.

Moreover, renting a car provides convenience in terms of storage. You can easily keep your beach gear, snorkeling equipment, and other belongings in the car without worrying about carrying them around or relying on lockers. This allows you to have a stress-free day at the beach and be fully prepared for any adventure that comes your way.

Uber Offers Convenience But Less Flexibility

If you prefer not to rent a car, Uber can be a convenient alternative for getting around Hawaii. With the click of a button, you can summon a ride and be on your way to your destination. Uber drivers are readily available in popular tourist areas, making it easy to catch a ride when you need one.

Uber offers convenience, especially if you are staying in a busy city like Honolulu, where parking can be a challenge. Instead of worrying about finding parking spaces or paying exorbitant parking fees, you can simply arrive at your destination and let your Uber driver handle the logistics.

However, it is important to note that Uber may not be as flexible as renting a car. You are limited to the availability of drivers and the areas they cover. If you want to explore remote areas or have the freedom to make spontaneous stops along the way, renting a car would be a better option.

Additionally, relying solely on Uber for transportation can be expensive, especially if you plan on traveling long distances or taking multiple trips throughout your stay in Hawaii. Rental cars often offer more cost-effective options, especially for longer durations.

Ultimately, the decision to rent a car or use Uber in Hawaii depends on your personal preferences and the nature of your trip. If you value convenience, flexibility, and the ability to explore the islands at your own pace, renting a car would be the ideal choice. However, if you prefer not to drive or have limited transportation needs, Uber can provide a convenient and hassle-free option for getting around.

Cost Comparison

Rental Cars Can Provide Better Value for Longer Trips

When deciding whether to rent a car or rely on Uber for transportation during your stay in Hawaii, one important factor to consider is the duration of your trip. If you plan on staying in Hawaii for an extended period of time, renting a car may be the more cost-effective option. Rental car rates typically decrease the longer you rent, allowing you to save money on transportation expenses.

Additionally, having a rental car gives you the freedom to explore the islands at your own pace. You can easily visit multiple attractions in a day without the hassle of waiting for an Uber to arrive or paying for multiple rides. This flexibility can enhance your overall experience and make your trip more enjoyable.

Uber Costs Add Up Quickly for Multiple Rides Each Day

On the other hand, if your trip to Hawaii is shorter and you don’t plan on doing a lot of sightseeing, relying on Uber may be a viable option. It’s important to note, however, that the costs of using Uber can add up quickly, especially if you are taking multiple rides each day.

While Uber may seem convenient at first, it’s crucial to consider the surge pricing that often occurs during peak travel times or in popular tourist areas. This can significantly increase the cost of your rides, making it less economical compared to renting a car for the duration of your trip.

Furthermore, if you’re traveling with a group or have a lot of luggage, Uber may not be the most practical choice. With a rental car, you have the space to comfortably accommodate both passengers and belongings.

Ultimately, the decision between renting a car or using Uber in Hawaii depends on the specifics of your trip. If you’re planning a longer stay and want the flexibility to explore multiple destinations, renting a car may offer better value. On the other hand, if you’re only in Hawaii for a short period and don’t plan on traveling extensively, using Uber can be a convenient option. Consider your budget, itinerary, and transportation needs to make the best decision for your trip.

Safety Considerations

Driving in Hawaii Comes With Some Risks

Before deciding whether to rent a car or rely on Uber in Hawaii, it’s important to consider the safety factors involved in driving yourself. While Hawaii is known for its beautiful landscapes and scenic drives, it’s also important to be aware of the potential risks. The narrow and winding roads, unfamiliar surroundings, and different driving rules can make navigating the island a bit challenging for visitors. Additionally, some areas in Hawaii may have limited parking spaces, which can cause inconvenience and frustration.

If you’re not familiar with driving on the right side of the road or if you’re not comfortable navigating unfamiliar terrain, it might be safer to opt for alternative transportation methods like Uber. This way, you can sit back, relax, and enjoy the stunning views without worrying about getting lost or dealing with the stress of driving in unfamiliar territory.

Uber Provides Peace of Mind Without Driving Yourself

If safety is your top priority and you prefer not to drive yourself, choosing Uber as your mode of transportation in Hawaii can offer peace of mind. Uber drivers are required to undergo background checks and meet certain safety standards, ensuring a secure and reliable experience for passengers. Additionally, the convenience of using the Uber app allows you to easily request a ride and track your driver’s location in real-time, making it a hassle-free option for getting around the island.

Another advantage of using Uber in Hawaii is the cost-effectiveness. Renting a car can come with additional expenses such as parking fees, gas, and insurance. With Uber, you can simply pay for the rides you take, without having to worry about these extra costs. Furthermore, Uber drivers are usually locals who are knowledgeable about the best routes and can provide valuable insights and recommendations about the island.

Ultimately, the decision between renting a car or using Uber in Hawaii depends on your personal preferences, comfort level with driving in unfamiliar areas, and your budget. Consider the safety factors and convenience of both options to make an informed choice that suits your needs best.

Accessing Off the Beaten Path Destinations

When it comes to exploring the beautiful islands of Hawaii, one of the key considerations is how to access the off the beaten path destinations. These hidden gems are often the highlight of any trip, offering breathtaking views, secluded beaches, and a chance to experience the true essence of Hawaii. Renting a car or using Uber are two popular options for getting around, each with their own advantages and drawbacks. Let’s take a closer look at how these two choices compare when it comes to accessing these lesser-known spots.

A Rental Car Unlocks Hidden Gems Across the Islands

Renting a car in Hawaii can be a great way to unlock the hidden gems across the islands. With a rental car, you have the freedom to explore at your own pace and venture off the beaten path. You can easily reach secluded beaches, hike to remote waterfalls, and visit charming local towns that may not be easily accessible by public transportation. Additionally, having a rental car allows you to explore multiple destinations in a single day, maximizing your time and giving you the flexibility to create your own itinerary.

One of the advantages of renting a car is the ability to explore the islands’ natural wonders. For example, on the Big Island, you can drive to the Mauna Kea summit and witness the breathtaking sunset from above the clouds. On Kauai, you can drive along the scenic Na Pali Coast and stop at various lookout points to take in the stunning views. These experiences are unique to each island and can be easily accessed with a rental car.

It’s worth noting that renting a car in Hawaii can be more expensive than using Uber or other ride-sharing services. However, if you plan to explore multiple destinations or have a group of people traveling together, the cost can be more affordable when divided among the group. Additionally, having a car allows you to store your belongings securely while you explore, without having to carry everything with you.

Uber Makes it Harder to Explore Lesser Known Spots

While Uber is convenient for getting around cities and popular tourist areas, it can make it harder to explore the lesser known spots in Hawaii. Ride-sharing services are primarily focused on urban areas, and their availability in more remote locations, such as secluded beaches or hiking trails, can be limited. This means that if you rely solely on Uber, you may miss out on some of the hidden gems that Hawaii has to offer.

Another drawback of using Uber is the lack of flexibility in terms of time and itinerary. With a rental car, you have the freedom to stop and explore whenever you come across something interesting. However, with Uber, you are bound by the availability of drivers and their schedules. This can be especially challenging if you want to visit multiple destinations in a day or if you prefer to have a more spontaneous travel experience.

Ultimately, the choice between renting a car or using Uber in Hawaii depends on your travel preferences and itinerary. If you are looking to explore the off the beaten path destinations and have the flexibility to create your own adventure, renting a car is the way to go. On the other hand, if you plan to stay primarily in urban areas and prefer the convenience of not having to drive, then Uber may be a more suitable option for you. Whichever option you choose, Hawaii is sure to offer an unforgettable experience filled with natural beauty and aloha spirit.

Tips for Saving on a Rental Car

Book Early for the Best Rates

When planning your trip to Hawaii, it’s always a good idea to book your rental car as early as possible. Rental car prices tend to increase as the date of your trip gets closer, so by booking in advance, you can often secure a better rate. Additionally, booking early gives you a wider selection of vehicles to choose from, ensuring that you get the type of car you want at a price that fits your budget.

According to a study conducted by Kayak, booking a rental car at least three weeks in advance can save you up to 15% on the total cost. So, if you know you’ll be needing a car during your Hawaiian vacation, don’t wait until the last minute to make your reservation.

Consider a Compact Car

When deciding on the type of rental car to choose, it’s worth considering a compact car. While it may not have the same level of luxury or space as a larger vehicle, a compact car can often save you money on both the rental price and fuel costs. Compact cars are generally more fuel-efficient, allowing you to explore the beautiful Hawaiian islands without breaking the bank at the gas station.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, compact cars can achieve fuel efficiency ratings of up to 35 miles per gallon on the highway. This means you can spend less on fuel and more on enjoying everything that Hawaii has to offer.

Look for Discounts and Coupon Codes

Before you book your rental car, be sure to do some research and look for any available discounts or coupon codes. Many rental car companies offer promotions or special deals that can help you save money. These discounts can range from discounts for AAA members, to deals for booking through certain websites, to coupon codes that can be found online.

One website that offers a variety of rental car discounts and coupon codes is RetailMeNot. They frequently update their listings, so you can find the most up-to-date discounts for your rental car needs.

By following these tips, you can save money on your rental car in Hawaii, allowing you to have more funds available to enjoy the beautiful sights, delicious food, and thrilling activities that the islands have to offer.

Getting Around Without a Rental Car

When planning a trip to Hawaii, one of the first decisions you’ll need to make is how you will get around. While renting a car is a popular choice for many travelers, it’s not the only option. In fact, depending on your specific needs and preferences, there are several alternative transportation methods that you can consider. In this article, we will explore some of the different ways you can get around the beautiful islands of Hawaii without having to rent a car.

Leverage Public Transportation

Hawaii offers a reliable and efficient public transportation system, particularly on the more populated islands such as Oahu and Maui. The bus services, operated by TheBus and Maui Bus, cover a wide range of destinations and are a budget-friendly option for getting around. Not only does taking the bus save you money, but it also allows you to sit back, relax, and enjoy the scenic views as you travel from one location to another. You can easily plan your routes and check the schedules online, making it convenient and hassle-free.

Use Taxis for One-Off Trips

If you prefer a more direct and flexible mode of transportation, taxis are readily available in Hawaii. While they may be more expensive than other options, they can be a convenient choice for short trips or when you have a lot of luggage. Taxis can be easily hailed from popular tourist areas, hotels, and airports. Additionally, ride-hailing services such as Uber and Lyft are also widely available, providing a convenient and reliable alternative to traditional taxis. Just a few taps on your smartphone and a driver will be on their way to pick you up!

Consider a Tour for Certain Destinations

For specific destinations or attractions that are harder to reach by public transportation, guided tours can be a great option. Whether you want to explore the scenic beauty of the Road to Hana in Maui or visit the famous Pearl Harbor in Oahu, there are numerous tour operators that offer a variety of options. These tours often include transportation to and from your hotel, allowing you to sit back and enjoy the experience without worrying about navigation or parking. Additionally, tour guides provide valuable insights and information about the destinations, enhancing your overall experience.

While renting a car in Hawaii can provide you with flexibility and freedom, it’s not the only way to get around. By leveraging public transportation, using taxis for short trips, and considering guided tours for certain destinations, you can explore the beautiful islands of Hawaii without the need for a rental car. So, whether you decide to take a scenic bus ride along the coast or hop in a taxi to explore the local cuisine, there are plenty of options to suit every traveler’s needs.


Deciding between renting a car versus relying on Uber in Hawaii comes down to your priorities in cost, convenience, flexibility, and access to more remote parts of the islands. For most travelers planning a longer stay, having your own rental car is the best way to maximize your time and explore Hawaii affordably at your own pace. But Uber can still be a viable option for shorter trips or for accessing destinations near major tourist hubs. Carefully consider your itinerary and budget to determine if a rental car or Uber is the better fit. Either way, you’re bound to have an unforgettable Hawaiian vacation.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts